- Free Consultation: 305-668-6410 Tap Here to Call Us
Maritime Litigation Update: February 8, 2025
This week’s maritime litigation update highlights a series of non-cruise ship maritime lawsuits, bringing attention to serious legal disputes involving luxury yachts, vessel collisions, unpaid maritime liens, and passenger injury claims. As the yachting industry expands and vessel traffic increases in busy waterways, these cases emphasize the legal risks for vessel owners, charter operators, and maritime service providers.
Among the lawsuits filed in the Southern District of Florida, plaintiffs are seeking damages related to wrongful death claims from high-speed vessel collisions, unpaid yacht repairs leading to vessel foreclosure, and personal injury lawsuits stemming from onboard accidents. The outcomes of these cases could impact maritime law, vessel liability, and passenger safety standards in the United States.
Texas Passenger files a lawsuit Against The Ritz-Carlton’s Evrima
Case: Shaun Wymes v. Cruise Yacht OpCo, Ltd. (Case No. 1:25-cv-20484)
Allegations: Negligence, failure to maintain onboard furniture, passenger injury
A Texas resident has filed a personal injury lawsuit against The Ritz-Carlton Yacht Collection, alleging that he suffered serious injuries after a chair collapsed beneath him while dining at a sushi bar aboard the Evrima, a luxury yacht operated by Cruise Yacht OpCo, Ltd.
According to the lawsuit, the defective chair was in a high-traffic dining area, and The Ritz-Carlton allegedly failed to inspect, maintain, or warn passengers about the risk of furniture failure. Wymes claims that as a result of the incident, he suffered severe injuries requiring medical treatment, ongoing pain, and loss of mobility.
This lawsuit raises questions about passenger safety on luxury yacht charters and whether yacht operators have a legal obligation to ensure all onboard furniture and fixtures meet safety standards. If successful, this case could push luxury yacht companies to implement more rigorous safety inspections and maintenance protocols to prevent similar incidents.
Wrongful Death Lawsuit Following Alleged High-Speed Boat Collision in Miami’s Intracoastal Waterway
Case: TNT Custom Marine, Inc. v. Estate of Vladyslav Zlotnyk (Case No. 1:25-cv-20482)
Allegations: Limitation of Liability Act defense, wrongful death claim, vessel collision
A fatal boating accident in Miami-Dade County’s Intracoastal Waterway has resulted in a wrongful death lawsuit involving a 42’ Yellowfin powerboat and a personal watercraft. The powerboat’s owner has filed a petition under the Limitation of Liability Act, seeking to limit or eliminate liability by alleging that the jet ski operators were reckless and caused the accident.
The estate of the deceased passenger may argue that the powerboat operator was negligent in failing to avoid the collision, and the court will determine whether the vessel owner should be held financially responsible for damages.
This case highlights the legal complexities of maritime accident claims, including:
- Who is at fault in a boating accident involving multiple vessels
- How the Limitation of Liability Act can be used by vessel owners to reduce financial exposure
- What legal options exist for families of wrongful death victims in maritime collisions
Maritime Lien Foreclosure Over Alleged Unpaid Yacht Repairs
Case: FlyHopCo, LLC v. M/Y Symphony (Case No. 0:25-cv-60172)
Allegations: Breach of contract, maritime lien foreclosure, unpaid vessel repairs
A Fort Lauderdale yacht repair company has filed a maritime lien foreclosure lawsuit against the owner of the M/Y Symphony, a 34.1-meter Westport motor yacht, seeking $74,000 in unpaid repair costs, maintenance fees, and dockage expenses. The lawsuit requests a U.S. Marshal vessel arrest and a court-ordered sale of the yacht to satisfy the debt.
This case illustrates the legal process for enforcing maritime liens and the potential consequences for yacht owners who fail to pay for repairs or services. Yacht owners facing similar disputes may need a maritime contract lawyer to defend against vessel seizure and foreclosure claims.
Breach of Maritime Contract & Yacht Lien Dispute Over Alleged Unpaid Marina Fees
Case: George Clements v. M/V Allegra (Case No. 1:25-cv-20512)
Allegations: Breach of contract, unpaid services, maritime lien enforcement
A Massachusetts-based yacht service provider is suing the owners of the 62-foot Azimut yacht Allegra, claiming $55,000 in unpaid marina fees, vessel maintenance, and repair services. The lawsuit seeks a judicial sale of the yacht to recover damages.
If the yacht is seized and sold, the case could set a precedent for enforcing maritime liens against vessel owners who refuse to pay for services. Yacht owners involved in similar disputes may require a maritime business lawyer to negotiate settlements, defend against liens, or pursue claims for unpaid services.
Legal Implications for the Maritime Industry
These lawsuits expose critical legal and financial risks for vessel owners, yacht operators, and maritime service providers, including:
- Liability in Boating Accidents – Can vessel owners limit financial responsibility under maritime law following fatal accidents?
- Maritime Lien Enforcement – What are the legal options for marinas, repair companies, and service providers to recover unpaid debts?
- Passenger Injury on Yachts – How can luxury yacht operators improve safety protocols to avoid liability for personal injury claims?
Key Takeaways from This Week’s Cases
- Yacht Passenger Injury Lawsuit: A Texas resident is suing The Ritz-Carlton Yacht Collection, alleging that he suffered severe injuries after a chair collapsed aboard the Evrima, sparking concerns over safety inspections aboard luxury yacht charters.
- Fatal Boating Collision & Wrongful Death Claim: A 42’ Yellowfin powerboat operator seeks liability protection under the Limitation of Liability Act after a jet ski collision resulted in a fatality in Miami’s Intracoastal Waterway.
- Maritime Lien Foreclosures for Unpaid Vessel Repairs: Fort Lauderdale yacht service providers are suing vessel owners for unpaid maintenance and dockage fees, seeking U.S. Marshal vessel arrests and court-ordered yacht sales.
- Breach of Maritime Contract Disputes: A yacht service provider is suing the owner of the 62-foot M/V Allegra for $55,000 in unpaid marina fees and vessel maintenance costs, highlighting the financial risks for vessel owners who fail to settle debts.
What’s Next?
As these cases progress, they could set legal precedents affecting vessel ownership, passenger safety on luxury yachts, and liability in maritime collisions. Will vessel owners successfully limit liability under federal maritime law, or will passengers and service providers hold them accountable for injuries and unpaid debts?
If you are a maritime worker, yacht owner, or injured passenger, these cases demonstrate the importance of understanding your legal rights and responsibilities under admiralty law. Consulting with a maritime accident lawyer, boating injury attorney, or vessel lien defense specialist may be essential to protecting your interests.
Stay tuned for more updates in Maritime Lawsuit Weekly, where we track the latest legal battles shaping the future of admiralty law, vessel ownership, and maritime liability.